The Ultimate Pastrami on Rye Sub: A Timeless Deli Classic

Introduction

The Pastrami on Rye Sub is not just a sandwich; it’s a culinary institution, a legendary creation that has graced deli counters for decades. Simple, yet rich in flavor, it’s one of those dishes that perfectly balances salty, savory, and slightly tangy elements. The heart of this iconic sandwich is the tender, smoky pastrami, the creamy Swiss cheese, the spicy kick of mustard or the smooth richness of Russian dressing, all tucked into the sturdy embrace of rye bread. It’s the kind of sandwich that feels like home—comforting, satisfying, and utterly delicious.

Whether you’re enjoying a quiet lunch at home or indulging in a classic deli experience, the Pastrami on Rye Sub never fails to deliver. Perfect for a quick bite or a more leisurely meal, this sandwich combines bold flavors and textures, making it one of the most beloved sandwiches around the world. In this guide, we’ll walk you through how to make this deli favorite from scratch, ensuring every bite is bursting with flavor.

The Story Behind the Pastrami on Rye Sub

The Pastrami on Rye Sub has deep roots in Jewish-American culinary history. Pastrami, which originated as a way to preserve meat through smoking and curing, made its way into the United States with Jewish immigrants in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It wasn’t long before pastrami became a popular deli meat, particularly in New York City, where delis began serving the now-famous Pastrami on Rye sandwiches.

Rye bread, with its hearty texture and slightly tangy flavor, became the perfect partner for pastrami. The combination of the savory meat with Swiss cheese and condiments like mustard or Russian dressing provided a delightful contrast of flavors, creating a sandwich that quickly became a staple in delis nationwide.

Over the years, the Pastrami on Rye Sub has evolved, but its core ingredients have remained the same. It’s a sandwich that celebrates the perfect blend of textures—crispy rye bread, melt-in-your-mouth pastrami, and the cool, creamy Swiss cheese. Whether served hot or cold, this deli delight has earned its place as a go-to comfort food.

Ingredients: What You’ll Need

Creating the perfect Pastrami on Rye Sub at home requires just a few simple ingredients. Here’s a breakdown of what you’ll need to gather for this iconic sandwich:

For the Pastrami on Rye Sub:

• Pastrami – 1 lb (lean, sliced thin)
• Swiss cheese – 4 slices (or more, depending on preference)
• Mustard or Russian dressing – 2 tablespoons (optional, based on personal taste)
• Pickles – 4-6 slices (dill pickles work best, but feel free to choose your favorite type)
• Rye bread or sub rolls – 2 (fresh, soft, but sturdy enough to hold the sandwich fillings)

Optional Ingredients:

• Sauerkraut – 1/2 cup (if you prefer a tangy, crunchy addition to your sandwich)
• Lettuce or tomato – if you want to add some freshness and crunch to your sub

This combination of pastrami, Swiss cheese, and condiments is all you need for the classic version of the sandwich. However, feel free to personalize it with additional toppings, depending on your preferences.

Instructions: How to Prepare the Perfect Pastrami on Rye Sub

The Pastrami on Rye Sub is remarkably easy to make, which is part of its charm. While some delis may serve their pastrami hot and others cold, we’ll cover how to prepare both styles so you can make it exactly how you like.

Step 1: Preparing the Ingredients

1. Heat the Pastrami (Optional): If you prefer your pastrami warm, heat it up in a skillet over medium heat for about 3-4 minutes, or until it’s heated through. Alternatively, you can heat it in the microwave for 30-45 seconds, depending on the amount.If you like the cold version of the sandwich, you can skip this step and use the pastrami directly from the deli.
2. Slice the Swiss Cheese: Slice the Swiss cheese into individual slices. You can adjust the quantity based on your preference for more or less cheese. If you want a gooier melt, feel free to use slightly thicker slices.
3. Prepare the Pickles: Slice the pickles into thin rounds, about 1/8-inch thick. If you prefer a tangy crunch, dill pickles are the classic choice. However, sweet pickles or bread-and-butter pickles will work as well.
4. Optional Step: Sauerkraut If you’re adding sauerkraut, drain it well using a strainer. If desired, lightly heat it in a small pan for a few minutes to give it extra flavor.
5. Slice the Rye Bread: Cut the rye bread or sub rolls in half lengthwise. If you’re using sub rolls, consider toasting the bread slightly for a little extra crunch. Rye bread should be soft yet sturdy enough to hold the filling.

Step 2: Assembling the Sub

1. Spread the Dressing: Once your bread is prepared, spread a generous layer of mustard or Russian dressing on the inside of both slices of bread. The mustard will add a sharp, tangy flavor, while the Russian dressing provides a creamier, milder alternative. Choose whichever one you prefer—or use both!
2. Layer the Ingredients: Start with the warm pastrami. Lay it evenly over the bottom slice of the bread. The heat will melt the cheese slightly, creating a delicious combination of textures.
3. Add the Swiss Cheese: Layer the Swiss cheese on top of the pastrami. If you’re heating the pastrami, the cheese should melt just a bit as you place it on top. For a cooler version, the cheese will stay perfectly intact, offering a creamy texture with each bite.
4. Top with Pickles and Sauerkraut: Next, place the pickle slices on top of the cheese. If you’re using sauerkraut, add a layer of that as well. The tart pickles and tangy sauerkraut create a wonderful contrast to the rich flavors of the pastrami and cheese.

Step 3: Serve and Enjoy

Once the sandwich is assembled, place the top half of the bread over the fillings and gently press down to compact it. You can slice the sandwich into manageable portions for easier eating or serve it whole for a heartier meal.

Variations: Customize Your Pastrami on Rye Sub

The Pastrami on Rye Sub is a versatile sandwich, so feel free to experiment with different flavors and textures. Here are some ideas for customizing the sandwich to suit your taste:

1. Try Different Cheeses: While Swiss cheese is the classic choice for this sandwich, you can switch things up with other cheeses such as provolone, cheddar, or even pepper jack for a spicy kick.
2. Add More Veggies: Consider adding lettuce, tomato, onions, or even a few slices of avocado for extra crunch and freshness. These additions work especially well if you like a lighter, fresher take on the sandwich.
3. Switch Up the Condiments: For a more traditional deli experience, try using both mustard and Russian dressing. You could also experiment with spicy mustard, honey mustard, or a tangy vinegar-based sauce to add a unique flavor profile.
4. Make it a Hot Pastrami Sandwich: If you’re a fan of hot sandwiches, you can toast the bread and melt the cheese under a broiler for a few minutes. This will create a crispy, gooey version of the sandwich that adds a satisfying crunch with every bite.
5. Try Different Breads: While rye bread is the classic, you can always experiment with other options. A soft, chewy baguette, whole wheat bread, or even a soft sub roll would work well for this sandwich.

Serving Tips for Special Occasions

The Pastrami on Rye Sub is perfect for a casual lunch or dinner, but it can also be served at more festive occasions. Here are some serving tips to elevate this classic sandwich for special gatherings:

1. Pair with Classic Sides: Serve your sandwich with traditional deli sides like coleslaw, potato salad, or dill pickle chips for a full deli experience. These side dishes complement the flavors of the pastrami beautifully.
2. Serve with a Beverage: A crisp pickle brine or a tangy lemonade pairs wonderfully with the flavors of the pastrami. For something more indulgent, opt for a classic New York egg cream or even a cold beer for a more relaxed vibe.
3. Presentation: For a more upscale touch, you can serve the sandwich on a wooden board with a side of small dipping sauces, such as mustard, Russian dressing, or even a tangy barbecue sauce.

FAQs: Everything You Need to Know

1. Can I use different bread for the sandwich? Yes, while rye bread is traditional, you can use any type of bread you prefer. A baguette, soft sub rolls, or even whole wheat bread can be used as alternatives.

2. Can I make this sandwich ahead of time? You can assemble the sandwich ahead of time, but it’s best to serve it fresh. If you want to make it ahead, store the assembled sandwich in an airtight container and refrigerate it. You can also prepare the ingredients in advance and assemble the sandwich right before serving.

3. How do I make the pastrami if I’m using raw meat? If you want to make pastrami from scratch, it involves marinating the meat, smoking it, and then cooking it slowly until tender. However, most people purchase pre-cooked, sliced pastrami from a deli to save time.

4. What if I don’t like mustard or Russian dressing? No problem! You can use mayonnaise, horseradish sauce, or any condiment of your choice. Feel free to get creative with your spreads.

5. Can I freeze the sandwich? While it’s best to enjoy the sandwich fresh, you can freeze the pastrami and rye bread separately. Reheat the pastrami before assembling the sandwich when you’re ready to eat.

Conclusion

The Pastrami on Rye Sub is an enduring classic that has stood the test of time. With its perfect balance of smoky pastrami, creamy Swiss cheese, tangy mustard or dressing, and sturdy rye bread, this sandwich is a must-try for any deli lover. Whether you’re craving a quick lunch or preparing a meal for friends and family, this timeless sandwich is sure to satisfy. The beauty of the Pastrami on Rye Sub lies in its simplicity—each ingredient comes together to create a harmonious flavor profile that’s hard to beat. So, go ahead and make your own version of this iconic sandwich, and enjoy every bite!

Pastrami on Rye Sub: A Timeless Deli Classic

---

• Author: mohcin Brenda
• Total Time: 10 minutes

Print Recipe

Print Recipe

Description

Imagine a busy afternoon, when hunger strikes, and you crave something hearty, flavorful, and satisfying. You’ve been on the go all day, and now it’s time for a quick meal that delivers on taste. Enter the Pastrami on Rye Sub. This classic deli sandwich is filled with rich, smoky pastrami, creamy Swiss cheese, tangy mustard or Russian dressing, and crunchy pickles—all tucked inside hearty rye bread. It’s the perfect balance of textures and flavors in every bite, sure to satisfy your cravings whether you’re having it for lunch, dinner, or a snack. Ideal for any day when you want something simple yet indulgent, this sub is the epitome of deli goodness

---

Ingredients

For the Pastrami on Rye Sub:

• Pastrami
• Swiss cheese
• Mustard or Russian dressing
• Pickles, sliced
• Optional: Sauerkraut
• Rye bread or sub roll

---

Instructions

Step 1: Preparation
Start by preparing your ingredients. If you’re using pastrami, warm it up in a skillet or microwave for a few minutes to enhance its flavors. Slice the Swiss cheese into manageable pieces, and set it aside. If you’re including sauerkraut, be sure to drain it well to prevent the sandwich from becoming soggy. Slice your pickles into thin rounds for easy layering.

Step 2: Assembly
Now, assemble your sub. Slice your rye bread or sub roll lengthwise to create the perfect vessel for your fillings. Spread a generous layer of mustard or Russian dressing on the inside of both pieces of bread—don’t skimp on this; it adds flavor and moisture. Begin layering with the warm pastrami, followed by Swiss cheese, sliced pickles, and sauerkraut if you’re using it.

Step 3: Serve
Once your sandwich is fully assembled, close the sandwich and press it gently to compact the ingredients. Slice it into manageable portions for easy enjoyment, and serve immediately.

Notes

Pastrami Preparation
If you’re using store-bought pastrami, it’s best to warm it up slightly before assembling the sandwich. This helps release the smoky flavors and ensures the pastrami is tender when you bite into it. You can heat it in a skillet over low heat or microwave it for about 30 seconds to 1 minute—just enough to make it warm and flavorful.

Bread Choice
While rye bread is the classic choice for this sandwich, feel free to experiment with different types of bread depending on your taste preferences. A hearty whole wheat bread or a soft sub roll can be a great alternative if you want a different texture or flavor. Just make sure the bread is sturdy enough to hold the ingredients without getting soggy.

• Prep Time: 5 minutes
• Cook Time: 5 minutes